Hold the Product Pitch for DMs After They Ask

Hold the Product Pitch for DMs After They Ask is a reddit & forums tactic for getting your first users: Never name your product in a first reply; help publicly, then share it only in a DM once the person explicitly asks, while hunting threads via daily pain-phrase searches.

It's a strong fit for teams of almost any kind, and works especially well for Founders whose customers vent about the problem on Reddit. As a reddit & forums play, plan for medium effort and expect results to arrive at a steady pace, all grounded in 1 linked primary source.

Reddit & forumsMedium effortMedium

Why does reddit & forums work for this?

Keeping promotion out of public replies sidesteps the spam signal entirely while still capturing genuinely interested people.

The exact steps (5)

The full step-by-step this founder ran, what they posted, where, and in what order, plus the watch-outs, is part of the library.

Unlock the steps · $29 oncePlus all 3,000+ tactics and the new ones we add weekly.

Sources

Works for
Any / universal

Frequently asked

How is the "Hold the Product Pitch for DMs After They Ask" tactic verified?
It is drawn from 1 primary source — a real founder write-up or interview, not generic advice. It is linked in the Sources section above so you can read the original account yourself.
How much effort is it and how fast are results?
It is medium effort, and results tend to be medium.
Where can I see the exact step-by-step?
The full step-by-step a founder ran, documented via Source — IndieHackers, is in the paid library.

Related tactics

Reddit & forumsMedium effort· Slow

The Give-Heavy Ratio (and the Stand-Alone Test)

A discipline for how often and how much you self-promote: post overwhelmingly helpful contributions and only occasionally, lightly, reference your product.

Read the steps →
Reddit & forumsMedium effort· Fast

Keep the Value On-Platform, Link at the Bottom

Instead of dropping a link to your site or video, paste the full substance directly into a self-post and tuck a small optional link at the very end for people who want more.

Read the steps →
Reddit & forumsLow effort· Medium

Reply Only Where Reddit Asked for a Solution

Answer Reddit threads where the OP explicitly describes the problem you solve or asks for a tool like yours, so your mention is welcomed instead of flagged as spam.

Read the steps →
Reddit & forumsLow effort· Medium

Target Hot, Recent Posts and Reply to Top Comments

Choose placement deliberately by sorting subs by hot, picking fresh posts, and replying under already-large comments to avoid getting buried.

Read the steps →
Reddit & forumsMedium effort· Medium

Post in Audience-Targeted Subreddits and Mine the Criticism

He posted in subreddits matched tightly to his audience (plus maker-friendly ones like r/SideProject and r/selfhosted) and used the harsh feedback to improve the product while collecting sign-ups.

Read the steps →
Reddit & forumsLow effort· Medium

Warm a New Reddit Account for a Week Before Posting

Spending about a week browsing and commenting on a fresh Reddit account so the platform doesn't throttle your launch post as bot activity.

Read the steps →

Get all 3,000+ tactics in one place

Filter by your product and channel, follow the exact steps, and get the new tactics we add every week. One payment, yours for good.